A Little Madness in Almost SpringI've incited a revolution. The city of Birmingham in England has banned the use of apostrophes in city documents, road signs, and mailing addresses. As a grammarian, I was outraged. I thus wrote the letter below to the City Council. I then proceded to unleash chaos.
I read the letter to the students after teaching a unit on apostrophes. THen we learned about business letters, and we wrote letters to the council. Today we made signs, banners, and created chants, for tomorrow we take to the streets in protest. We are going to march through the neighborhoods chanting for the lowly flying comma. Examples include:
123's ABC's--they all need apostrophes!
Show possession, show show possession!
Bring back the apostrophe. . . we want English the way it was meant to be!!
Everyone in the school has since gotten into it--the kids have made apostrophe hats, shirts, banners, and the band has decided to play as we walk down the street. The protest will be video taped, and the principal has threatened to call the news media to alert them to the even.
Everyone needs a little whimsy sometimes.
Here's the letter:
City Council Members
Birmingham City Council
Council House
Victoria Square
Birmingham, England B1 1BB
To whom it may concern:
I feel it necessary to lodge a protest against your recent degradation of the English language. The banishment of the apostrophe from addresses and street signs is an assault against not only grammar but also the concept of following rules and adhering to what is right.
The apostrophe is not some fusty punctuation mark that has seen better days; rather, it is an integral part of the English tradition. When Councilor Martin Mullaney claimed, “They confuse people. If I want to go to a restaurant, I don’t want to have an A-level in English to find it” he really demeans the intelligence of those he serves. As a teacher of grammar and composition, I spend quite a bit of time teaching punctuation rules. The comma (that little minx!) has over seventeen rules, some of which are open to interpretation. Even the semi-colon and the colon can be a little difficult to interpret. The apostrophe, in contrast, has only three rules and takes up only a page in a text book. If my sixth, seventh, and eighth graders can quickly and easily master the concept in one lesson, surely it would not take intensive study for the undoubtedly intelligent people of Birmingham. I would be willing to give lessons!
More than simply violating the rules of grammar, set down to aide and regulate communication, your denigration of the humble apostrophe sends a distressing message to today’s youth. (Note the use of apostrophe!) The policy of the City of Birmingham tells young people that it is okay to take short cuts, that close enough is good enough, and that one need not follow those rules that might be inconvenient. As a teacher these are attitudes that I battle every day, and I didn’t (another apostrophe!) think that such an esteemed city would espouse the view that rules, customs and traditions are worthless. We must fight the dumbing down of society, not aide it. As civic leaders, you have a responsibility to promote competence, hard work and attention to detail rather than falling prey to the “everybody’s doing it, why shouldn’t we?” excuses.
Apostrophes, far from being old fashioned and confusing, help to provide order to an often disorderly world. I humbly ask that you reconsider this affront to the Queen’s English.
With respect,
Amanda Bresie
If you can, please send your own letter. Stop this atrocity!
Days like today I rememer why I got into this gig.